Window to the past ~ Colour or Black and White?
Today I went back to a pioneer cabin I visited last year. It was closed but, once again, I played with reflections and photographed a window through another window. I love B&W for its timeless quality but I also love light through colored glass. Which one do you prefer?
Valérie Jardin's Blog 
Love the B&W but how fabulous would colour bottles look superimposed in the B&W? Just found your work. Very special!
LikeLike
The color one is much nicer. The colors are all wonderfully filling the photograph while in the black and white version, it almost seems as if the lighting is off.
LikeLike
les choix sont partagés : Camille et Robin préfèrent la 1 ère,le noir et blanc sont en adéquation avec le sujet. J’aime bien les deux mais ma forte astigmatie me fait préférer la 2 nde en couleur,car elle m’offre plus de contraste!
LikeLike
Both a great but I really like the Black and White!
LikeLike
The color in those bottles is irresistable.
LikeLike
Argh! Too hard to choose… I like them both, they do both have their own story to tell.
LikeLike
id say the colour one is better. many details are gone in b and w. mostly the colour of the nbottles
LikeLike
Valerie, I’ve been back to look at this photo a number of times, as it’s fascinating. Did you by any chance place the 3 coloured glass bottles on the inside window? I don’t think the picture works without them.
LikeLike
Thanks George! No, this is not a set up. Yet I don’t think anyone ever notices how fascinating the reflections look and those beautiful vintage bottles…. I’ve never been inside this old building, looks abandoned.
LikeLike
N&B sans hésiter pour le coté “magique”!!
Bonne fin de week-end,
Bises à toute la famille
LikeLike
I like both too but if I had to choose then the blue bottle has it.
LikeLike
I like both to ; but B&W is my favorite
LikeLike
I like both but some subjects lend themselves better to black and white. It can be more dramatic. My all time favorite photographer is Ansel Adams and most of his work was in black and white. Keep up your good work in both mediums.
Vi
LikeLike
both are great, but the three coloured bottles really give a touch
LikeLike
I love the high contrast b/w as that’s where my bias is, but the muted colors does show more about the passage of time. Both photos are beautiful, but for me, color wins this round. Great work, Valerie.
LikeLike
black and white … nice clicks
LikeLike
Normally I would go straight for the Black and White, but on this occasion I like seeing the brown earth/leaves of the ground outside reflected. I think the brown of the rocking chair also gives a sense of age & time passing. Interesting that Kate sees the B & W as a reflection of time passing whereas I see the coloured image as time passing.
(Perhaps not enough greys in the image to be effective as a Black & White).
LikeLike
Definitely the black and white.
LikeLike
I think I’m leaning toward the B&W one. My eyes focus on different things with each photograph. I think the black and white image matches what the place seems–vacant, ghostly, from a past time.
LikeLike
I really like the black and white one 🙂
LikeLike
I like the b/w and color version
LikeLike
I love both of them . . . hard to pick a favourite.
LikeLike